On this page

Short answer: if you have natural gas, use it: it never runs out during an outage, there is no tank to buy or refill, and it usually costs less per hour. Choose propane if you do not have gas service. Propane gives a little more power from the same generator and stores for years, but runtime depends on your tank. A 500-gallon tank runs a 22 kW generator for about 4 to 7 days nonstop, depending on load.
How we calculated: we used Generac’s published fuel consumption for the Guardian 22 kW and standard propane tank fill levels. Fuel costs are rough national ranges; check your local rates.
Natural gas vs propane at a glance
| Natural gas | Propane | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel supply | Utility line, unlimited during most outages | On-site tank, limited by size |
| Output (Generac 22 kW example) | 19.5 kW | 22 kW |
| Fuel use at half load (22 kW) | About 228 cu ft per hour | About 2.5 gallons per hour |
| Rough fuel cost per day at half load | About $55 to $110 | About $150 to $210 |
| Extra equipment | Gas line, sometimes a larger meter | Tank, regulators and line |
| Refills | None | Delivery; plan ahead for storms |
| Best for | Homes with gas service | Rural homes and homes without gas |
Fuel use from Generac Guardian 22 kW specs. Cost estimates assume about $1 to $2 per therm for natural gas and $2.50 to $3.50 per gallon for propane.
Why output is lower on natural gas
Natural gas carries less energy per cubic foot than propane, so the same engine makes a little less power on it. Most air-cooled standby generators are rated about 10% lower on natural gas. The Generac Guardian 22 kW, for example, is rated 22 kW on propane and 19.5 kW on natural gas. If you are on natural gas and close to the limit, size up. Our generator sizing guide explains how.
How long will a propane tank run a generator?
Propane tanks are filled to about 80% to leave room for expansion, so a 500-gallon tank holds about 400 usable gallons. Using the Guardian 22 kW’s published burn rates:
| Tank size | Usable gallons | At half load (about 2.5 gal/hr) | At full load (about 3.9 gal/hr) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 250 gallons | About 200 | About 3 days | About 2 days |
| 500 gallons | About 400 | About 6.5 days | About 4 days |
| 1,000 gallons | About 800 | About 13 days | About 8.5 days |
Most homes run well below half load most of the time, so real-world runtime is often longer. If your home also heats with propane, plan for that use too.
Installation differences
- Natural gas: a gas fitter runs a line from the meter. The utility may need to upgrade the meter or regulator so it can supply the generator at full load along with your furnace and water heater.
- Propane: you buy or lease a tank, place it per code, and run a line with regulators. Underground tanks cost more but hide the tank.
- Both: the line must be sized for the generator’s full-load fuel use, and both need permits. See standby generator installation.
Can a generator use both?
Most air-cooled home standby generators can be set up for either natural gas or propane, but they run on one at a time, chosen during installation. Some portable generators are dual or tri fuel and can switch between gasoline, propane and natural gas; see our best inverter generator picks. If you have neither fuel, consider diesel standby or a battery system.
Which generator should you buy?
Any of the models in our best whole house generators guide work with either fuel. For cost details, see whole house generator cost.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to run a generator on natural gas or propane?
Natural gas is usually cheaper per hour. At half load, a 22 kW generator might use about $55 to $110 of natural gas per day versus about $150 to $210 of propane, depending on local prices.
How long will a 500-gallon propane tank run a whole house generator?
About 4 days at full load and about 6.5 days at half load for a 22 kW generator, and longer at the lighter loads most homes actually use.
Does natural gas stop during a power outage?
Rarely. Natural gas is delivered by pipeline pressure and usually keeps flowing during electric outages, though major disasters like earthquakes can interrupt it.
Do generators make less power on natural gas?
Yes, typically about 10% less. The Generac Guardian 22 kW makes 22 kW on propane and 19.5 kW on natural gas.
Can I switch my standby generator from propane to natural gas?
Usually yes, with a fuel conversion done by a qualified technician. The fuel line, regulator settings and permits must match the new fuel.


